الرواه الذين أخرج لهم الشيخان وتكلم فيهم العقيلي في تراجمهم في الضعفاء ووثقهم ابن حجر في تقريب التهديب: دراسة ونقد

الملخص EN

The number of the biographies mentioned in the research is fifteen biographies.

ibn Hagar agreed with al`Uqayly on one biography out of fifteen.

ibn Hagar`s verdict concerning the narrators was fair except for only one narrator.

al`Uqayly, on the other hand, is tough on criticizing the narrators, since it`s been proven that most of the narrators whom he spoke of were reliable.

also, all the reasons he gave for his verdict were weak.

al`Uqayly often inserted Hadith Munkar (unknown hadith) in the biography of one narrator which he didn`t transmit and criticism is to be directed to the one beneath him in the chain of narrators.

nevertheless, al`Uqayly is one of the accredited imams of the science of impugnment and validation, well-acquainted with hidden defects of Ḥadith.