بين النحاة و المحدثين : دراسة في شواهد نبوية استشهد بها النحاة و ليس لها أصل في كتب السنة

الملخص EN

The grammarians relied on the noble Prophet's hadith and cited it in proving the grammar rules, but some of them cited hadiths that were not proven from the Prophet and were not mentioned in the books of the Sunnah, but you can only find them in the books of grammarians.

This study deals with a range of those hadiths, and places them on the carpet of research, investigation, consideration and scrutiny.

The study concluded that these hadiths cannot be invoked to prove and report grammatical rules.

Because what is meant by citing the hadith in grammar is the expression, not the meaning, so the citation is not valid except with what is proven by a text or presumption that it is from the words of the Prophet.

The study recommended the necessity to purify grammar books from hadiths that have no basis, and to alert researchers that these hadiths are not suitable for grammatical protest, and to search - in return for that - for established hadiths that are valid for citation to be a substitute for the one that has no basis, and in that it enriches the grammatical evidences.