الشك في كتب التراث بين الذاتية و الموضوعية : كتاب نهج البلاغة أنموذجا

الملخص EN

SUSPECT has been leaked to a number of heritage books such as “AL AIN” of Khalil bin Ahmed Faraheedi and others, and it has been highly controversial denial and proof for various reasons, some being technicalsome relevant to the documentary evidence, and some concerning the content of the manuscript.

here were many motives to this suspect, and among the books that were argued is “NAHJ AL BALAGHA” which was put together by Al Sharif Al Razi (406 AH) in which he collected sermons, letters, admonitions and the philosophies of Ali bin Abi Talib, then circulated and publicized among the people, became renowned, and was annotated and commented on by many writers, until Supreme Judge Ibn Khalkan (681 AH), author of the book “WAFIYAT AL A’AYAN” suspected the book.

This suspect was then became vested to others.

This research addresses the scientific value of this suspect the motives that led to it, then the study of the book and the extent of its correctness, objectivity of the suspect, a look at the responses, to evaluate the scientific term of this suspect.