دراسة نقدية مقارنة، مع سبر مرويات المساتير عند ابن حجر، و قال فيهم الذهبي "صدوق"

الملخص EN

Narrators considered of unrevealed condition by Ibn Hajar and trustworthy by Al-Zahabi are Abu Al-Hakam Al-Bajali and Hafs bin Bughail.

The research identifies the two terms and adopts the approach of investigating the narrator's narrations, proving that Al-Bajaly has five students and not four as stated by critics.

He is openly known to be just.

He has three narrations, two of which were reported by other narrators from the same companion.

He reported the third Hadith from Abu Huraira and Abu Said Al-Khadri.

His narration from Al-Khadri was reported by other Tabi's, but his narration from Abu Huraira was not.

However, the two narrations were reported by other companions.

Bin Bughail has four students and nine narrations, eight of which were reported by other narrators from the same companion.

The ninth Hadith was "discontinued"; not narrated by anyone else.

The research gives more weight to Al-Zahabi's judgment of the two narrators.

The research recommends applying the approach of investigating the narrator's narrations with comparing and overweighing the contradicting sayings of Al-Zahabi and Ibn Hajar.