Cost-effectiveness of kidney transplantation compared with chronic dialysis in end-stage renal disease

الملخص EN

To estimate the costs and effectiveness measured in quality-adjusted life years (QALY) of kidney transplantation compared with dialysis in adults suffering from end-stage renal disease from the perspective of the Colombian healthcare system, we designed a Markov model with monthly cycles over a five-year time horizon and eight transitional states, including death as an absorbing state.

Transition probabilities were obtained from international registries, costs from different local sources [case studies, official tariffs (ISS 2001 + 35%) for procedures and SISMED for medications].

Data were validated by an expert panel and we performed univariate, multivariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses.

Effectiveness indicators were months of life gained, months of dialysis averted and deaths prevented.

The annual discount rate was 3% and the cost-utility threshold (willingness to pay) was three times gross domestic product (GDP) = USD 20,000 per QALY.

The costs were adopted in US dollars (USD) using the 2012 average exchange rate (1 USD = COP$ 1798).

The discounted average total cost for five years was USD 76,718 for transplantation and USD 76,891 for dialysis, with utilities 2.98 and 2.10 QALY, respectively.

Additionally, renal transplantation represented 6.9 months gained, 35 months in dialysis averted per patient and one death averted for each of the five patients transplanted in five years.

We conclude that renal transplantation improves the overall survival rates and quality of life and is a cost-saving alternative compared with dialysis.