تمنطق النحو : بين مدكور وجيرار تروبو

الملخص EN

It is not a new issue to talk about «logic effect in Arabian grammar».

Dozens of works wrote as a book, an article, and a chapter of a scientific thesis.

My contribution in this research is not to increase the writings, or to repeat something ancestor of them, but I've seen most of who wrote about it either refuter never, and either a supporter at all, and either seeker in to mediate, which is in fact combines between the two views, or fabricator a third view, I did not find someone who was a neutral in his discussion for both the two views as scientifically going away of any influent.

So i saw that i oppose the prover's view with the denier's view, then do the conversely, on scientific table seriously, discussing the argument both, inspecting in the answer of every one of them, using the assets of controversy in all of that, and pure impartiality, according to what is known as analysis of the knowledge-or the theory of knowledge (= Epistemology), I chose for the parties to the dispute the two famous of who the issue had been known by them, one of them: Dr.

Ibrahim Bayoumi Madkour because that his opinion to prove effect was recap what the orientalists before him said, and he showed it as arranged show, and the other: orientalist German «Gerard Troupeau», because he was the representative the scientists who deny idea of this effect , discusser with a deep breath.