Process Evaluation of Workplace Interventions with Physical Exercise to Reduce Musculoskeletal Disorders

Abstract EN

Process evaluation is important to explain success or failure of workplace interventions.

This study performs a summative process evaluation of workplace interventions with physical exercise.

As part of a randomized controlled trial 132 office workers with neck and shoulder pain were to participate in 10 weeks of elastic resistance training five times a week at the workplace; the 2 min group performed a single set of lateral raise to failure, and the 12 min group performed 5-6 sets with 8–12 repetitions.

Participants received a single instructional session together with a training diary and manual at baseline (100% dose delivered and 100% dose received), and 59 and 57 participants, respectively, replied to the process evaluation questionnaire at 10-week follow-up.

Results showed that in the 2 and 12 min groups, respectively, 82% and 81% of the participants completed more than 30 training sessions.

However, two-thirds of the participants would have preferred more than a single exercise to vary between.

In the 12 versus 2 min group more participants experienced the training sessions as too long (30% versus 5%).

Most participants (67–92%) found the training diary and manual helpful, adequacy in a single instructional session, and satisfaction with the type of training.

Among those with low adherence, lack of time (51%) and difficulties in starting exercising after illness (26%) were common barriers for regular training.

Among those with low adherence, 52% felt that five training sessions per week were too much, and 29% would rather have trained a completely different kind of exercise.

In conclusion, resistance training at the workplace is generally well received among office workers with neck-shoulder pain, but a one-size-fits-all approach is not feasible for all employees.