Do DSM-5 Eating Disorder Criteria Overpathologize Normative Eating Patterns among Individuals with Obesity?
Joint Authors
Thomas, Jennifer J.
Koh, Katherine A.
Eddy, Kamryn T.
Hartmann, Andrea S.
Murray, Helen B.
Gorman, Mark J.
Sogg, Stephanie
Becker, Anne E.
Source
Issue
Vol. 2014, Issue 2014 (31 Dec. 2014), pp.1-8, 8 p.
Publisher
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Publication Date
2014-06-26
Country of Publication
Egypt
No. of Pages
8
Main Subjects
Abstract EN
Background.
DSM-5 revisions have been criticized in the popular press for overpathologizing normative eating patterns—particularly among individuals with obesity.
To evaluate the evidence for this and other DSM-5 critiques, we compared the point prevalence and interrater reliability of DSM-IV versus DSM-5 eating disorders (EDs) among adults seeking weight-loss treatment.
Method.
Clinicians (n=2) assigned DSM-IV and DSM-5 ED diagnoses to 100 participants via routine clinical interview.
Research assessors (n=3) independently conferred ED diagnoses via Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV and a DSM-5 checklist.
Results.
Research assessors diagnosed a similar proportion of participants with EDs under DSM-IV (29%) versus DSM-5 (32%).
DSM-5 research diagnoses included binge eating disorder (9%), bulimia nervosa (2%), subthreshold binge eating disorder (5%), subthreshold bulimia nervosa (2%), purging disorder (1%), night eating syndrome (6%), and other (7%).
Interrater reliability between clinicians and research assessors was “substantial” for both DSM-IV (κ = 0.64, 84% agreement) and DSM-5 (κ = 0.63, 83% agreement).
Conclusion.
DSM-5 ED criteria can be reliably applied in an obesity treatment setting and appear to yield an overall ED point prevalence comparable to DSM-IV.
American Psychological Association (APA)
Thomas, Jennifer J.& Koh, Katherine A.& Eddy, Kamryn T.& Hartmann, Andrea S.& Murray, Helen B.& Gorman, Mark J.…[et al.]. 2014. Do DSM-5 Eating Disorder Criteria Overpathologize Normative Eating Patterns among Individuals with Obesity?. Journal of Obesity،Vol. 2014, no. 2014, pp.1-8.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1042338
Modern Language Association (MLA)
Thomas, Jennifer J.…[et al.]. Do DSM-5 Eating Disorder Criteria Overpathologize Normative Eating Patterns among Individuals with Obesity?. Journal of Obesity No. 2014 (2014), pp.1-8.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1042338
American Medical Association (AMA)
Thomas, Jennifer J.& Koh, Katherine A.& Eddy, Kamryn T.& Hartmann, Andrea S.& Murray, Helen B.& Gorman, Mark J.…[et al.]. Do DSM-5 Eating Disorder Criteria Overpathologize Normative Eating Patterns among Individuals with Obesity?. Journal of Obesity. 2014. Vol. 2014, no. 2014, pp.1-8.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1042338
Data Type
Journal Articles
Language
English
Notes
Includes bibliographical references
Record ID
BIM-1042338