Alkali Effect on Alkali-Surfactant-Polymer (ASP)‎ Flooding Enhanced Oil Recovery Performance: Two Large-Scale Field Tests’ Evidence

Abstract EN

Alkali-surfactant-polymer (ASP) flooding is very promising chemical enhanced oil recovery (EOR) technology which can make an incremental oil recovery factor (IORF) of 30% original oil in place (OOIP).

How to choose alkali in ASP flooding remains a question for a long time.

As the world’s only and largest ASP flooding application place, Daqing Oilfield has always adhered to the strategy of parallel development of strong alkali ASP flooding (SASP) and weak alkali ASP flooding (WASP), but SASP is in a dominant position, indicated by more investments and more project numbers.

This leaves an impression that SASP is better than WASP.

However, WASP is drawing more interest than SASP recently.

Moreover, as the ASP flooding in Daqing went from field tests to commercial applications since 2014, how to comprehensively consider the benefit and cost of ASP flooding has become a new focus at low oil prices.

This paper compares two typical large-scale field tests (B-1-D SASP and B-2-X WASP) completed in Daqing Oilfield and analyzes and discusses the causes of this difference.

The injection viscosity and interfacial tension (IFT) for the two field test areas are substantially equivalent under the conditions of Daqing Oilfield, and WASP is better than SASP when reservoir geological conditions are considered.

WASP exhibits the same IORF of 30% as SASP while having a much better economic performance.

For the SASP field test, the injected strong alkali NaOH makes the test behave unlike a typical strong ASP flooding due to the presence of CO2 in the formation fluid, which well explains why IORF is much higher than all the other SASPs but scaling is less severe than others.

This paper confirms that under Daqing Oilfield reservoir conditions, it is the alkali difference that caused the performance difference of these two tests, although some minor uncertainties exist.

WASP is better than the SASP providing the same conditions .

In addition, the detailed information of the two ASP field tests provided can give reference for the implementation of ASP flooding in other oilfields.

After all, the study of ASP flooding enhanced oil recovery technology under low oil prices requires great foresight and determination.