Tumor Volume Kinetic Analyses Might Explain Excellent Prognoses in Young Patients with Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma

Abstract EN

Introduction.

Young patients with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) generally have excellent prognoses despite their often-advanced disease status.

The reasons for this excellent prognosis are poorly understood.

Objective.

To investigate the natural history of PTC in young patients, we compared the observed tumor volume-doubling rate (TV-DR) with the hypothetical tumor volume-doubling rate (hTV-DR) before presentation in young PTC patients.

DR is an inverse of the doubling time and indicates the number of doublings that occur in a unit of time.

A negative value indicates the number of times the volume is reduced by half per unit time.

Methods.

We enrolled 20 patients with the following characteristics: age ≤19 years, diagnosed with PTC according to the cytology results between 2013 and 2018 and followed-up with periodical ultrasound examinations for ≥3 months before surgery for various reasons.

Seventeen patients later underwent surgery confirming the diagnosis.

We calculated TV-DRs using serial measurements of tumor diameters after presentation and hTV-DRs using tumor diameters and patients’ age at presentation, assuming that a single cancer cell was present at the patient’s birth and that the tumor grew at a constant rate.

These values indicate the lowest growth rates necessary for a single cancer cell to achieve the full tumor size at presentation.

Results.

Thirteen patients had positive TV-DRs (/year) ranging from 0.09 to 1.89, indicating tumor growth, and the remaining seven patients had negative values (−0.08 to −1.21), indicating regression.

The median TV-DR was 0.29.

The hTV-DRs (1.48–2.66, median 1.71) were significantly larger than the TV-DRs (p<0.001), indicating much faster growth before presentation.

Conclusions.

These data suggest that deceleration of tumor growth had already occurred at presentation in the majority of the cases.

This might explain why disease-specific survival is excellent despite frequent findings of advanced disease in young patients with PTC.