تعارض وصل الحديث و إرساله : حديث "لا نكاح إلا بولي" أنموذجا

Abstract EN

The subject of knowing contradictory narrations in the chain of narrators and texts is one of the difficult matters that only expert scholars can do.

what is meant by the contradiction of the connection and transmission is : that the hadith be narrated once with a chain of transmission connected to the messenger of god, and once with a send chain of transmission.

it is not mentioned after the Tabiai.

this is according to the opinion of many hadiths regarding the definition of the sender.

and the scholars have four sayings in defending the contradiction of the connection and transmission: first: the priority of communication over transmission is absolute.

the second: weighing the transmission over the connection at all.

the third : the weighting according to the weights.

fourth: the equality between the two narratives and the pause.

the modernists doctrine weighting according to the weights.

the hadith “there is no marriage but for me” is considered one of the applied models on the issue of the difference in the connection and transmission of the hadith, and among the companions on whom this hadith was narrated by Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, may god be pleased with him, and he differed over Shu'bah bin al-Hajjaj and Sufyan al-Thawri in its connection and transmission.

the scholars preferred the linked narration over the narration transmitted with clues.