ردود على شبهات كارل بروكلمان في موقفه من السيرة النبوية : دراسة نقدية لكتاب تاريخ الشعوب الإسلامية

Abstract EN

Schools of Orientalism are various, and their areas of research expanded too, where Orientalists – regardless of their affiliation – had written about everything related to Islam and Muslims, and these descriptions were based on their relationship with the ecclesiastical institutions in Europe on one hand, and the latest scientific research methods that have been reached in the Western civilization on the other hand.

Yet, it is noticeable that they were highly influenced by the Church to the extent that many of them had deliberately twisted the clear facts if they contradicted what they believed in.

Among these Orientalists, Karl Brockelmann, in spite of the reputation that he gains in the Western and Eastern worlds, his approach to writing the biography of the Prophet, may God's prayers and peace be upon him, was full of strangeness, and his judgments were weak, and they were merely a repetition of what the Orientalists who preceded him.

Therefore, we tried to respond to him in a scientific manner and attempted to clarify the errors that he committed.