نظرات نقدية في مسألة ظنية أصول تصحيح الروايات
Other Title(s)
Critical views on the issue of presumptive nature of the principles of authenticating narrations
Author
الحرازي، مشهور بن مرزوق بن محمد
Source
Issue
Vol. 6, Issue 11 (31 Aug. 2022), pp.5-39, 35 p.
Publisher
Endowment for Cherishing the Two Glorious Revelations
Publication Date
2022-08-31
Country of Publication
Saudi Arabia
No. of Pages
35
Main Subjects
Abstract EN
Research Topic : Study on the issue of presumptive nature of principles of authenticating narrations.
Main Objective of the Study : Critiquing the view that the principles of authenticating narrations are totally presumptive hence some people are using this view to reject ahadith that are agreed upon by scholars of hadith as authentic, in a way that is not consistent with scientific methodology.
Research Problem : What exactly are these principles? What is their position in terms of certainty and presumption? How do we regulate the view that their results are presumptive? What is the origin of the difference resulting from the principles of authentication? Who are the first proponents of the view that they are totally presumptive? What led to this view? What are the probable arguments in its favour and the response to them? Research Findings: 1-That the principles of authenticating narrations are certain in their conditions, and at the same time we are confident in the rulings derived from them.
As for the view that these principles are presumptive in their conditionality, or that the results from them are presumptive, this is an innovation.
2-That the rulings derived from principles of authentication are matters of scholarly efforts.
However, that should not cast doubt on every ruling derived from them claiming that it is presumptive and based on scholarly effort.
3-The first person to come up with the view that the principles of authenticating narrations are presumptive is Sheikh Dhafar Ahmad al-Uthmani at-Tah-anawi (Died 1394 AH), and what led him to this is his attempt to defend the Hanafi school of thought and refute its oppositions.
American Psychological Association (APA)
الحرازي، مشهور بن مرزوق بن محمد. 2022. نظرات نقدية في مسألة ظنية أصول تصحيح الروايات. مجلة تعظيم الوحيين،مج. 6، ع. 11، ص ص. 5-39.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1435975
Modern Language Association (MLA)
الحرازي، مشهور بن مرزوق بن محمد. نظرات نقدية في مسألة ظنية أصول تصحيح الروايات. مجلة تعظيم الوحيين مج. 6، ع. 11 (آب 2022)، ص ص. 5-39.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1435975
American Medical Association (AMA)
الحرازي، مشهور بن مرزوق بن محمد. نظرات نقدية في مسألة ظنية أصول تصحيح الروايات. مجلة تعظيم الوحيين. 2022. مج. 6، ع. 11، ص ص. 5-39.
https://search.emarefa.net/detail/BIM-1435975
Data Type
Journal Articles
Language
Arabic
Notes
يتضمن هوامش.
Record ID
BIM-1435975