Human Behaviour Analysis of Barrier Deviations Using a Benefit-Cost-Deficit Model

Abstract EN

A Benefit-Cost-Deficit (BCD) model is proposed for analyzing such intentional human errors as barrier removal, the deliberate nonrespect of the rules and instructions governing use of a given system.

The proposed BCD model attempts to explain and predict barrier removal in terms of the benefits, costs, and potential deficits associated with this human behaviour.

The results of an experimental study conducted on a railway simulator (TRANSPAL) are used to illustrate the advantages of the BCD model.

In this study, human operators were faced with barriers that they could choose to deactivate, or not.

Their decisions were analyzed in an attempt to explain and predict their choices.

The analysis highlights that operators make their decisions using a balance between several criteria.

Though barriers are safety-related elements, the decision to remove them is not guided only by the safety criterion; it is also motivated by such criteria as productivity, workload, and quality.

Results of prediction supported by the BCD demonstrate the predictability of barrier violation