Comparing Years of Healthy Life, Measured in 16 Ways, for Normal Weight and Overweight Older Adults

Abstract EN

Introduction.

The traditional definitions of overweight and obesity are not age specific, even though the relationship of weight to mortality is different for older adults.

Effects of adiposity on aspects of health beside mortality have not been well investigated.

Methods.

We calculated the number of years of healthy life (YHL) in the 10 years after baseline, for 5,747 older adults.

YHL was defined in 16 different ways.

We compared Normal and Overweight persons, classified either by body mass index (BMI) or by waist circumference (WC).

Findings.

YHL for Normal and Overweight persons differed significantly in 25% of the comparisons, of which half favored the Overweight.

Measures of physical health favored Normal weight, while measures of mental health and quality of life favored Overweight.

Overweight was less favorable when defined by WC than by BMI.

Obese persons usually had worse outcomes.

Discussion.

Overweight older adults averaged as many years of life and years of healthy life as those of Normal weight.

There may be no outcome based reason to distinguish Normal from Overweight for older adults.

Conclusion.

The “Overweight paradox” appears to hold for nonmortality outcomes.

New adiposity standards are needed for older adults, possibly different by race and sex.